The Immortality of the Soul Proven from Scripture & Reason

Immortality of the Soul_Proven from Scripture and Reason

John Flavel
A Treatise of the Soul of Man
pp. 81-120

Revelation 6.9-11.
And when he had opened the Fifth Seal, I saw under the Altar the Souls of them that were slain for the Word of God, and for the Testimony which they held. And they cried with a loud Voice, saying, How long, O Lord! holy and true, dost thou not judge and a­venge our Blood on them that dwell on the Earth? And white Robes were given unto every one of them, and it was said unto them, That they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellow Servants also, and their Brethren, that should be killed as they were, should be fulfilled.

Having from the former text spoken of the Na­ture of the Soul, and the tie betwixt it and the Body; I shall from this Scripture evince the Immortality of the Soul, which is a chief part of its Excellency and Glory. And in this Scripture it hath a firm Foundation.

This Book of the Revelation completes and seals up the whole Sacred Canon (Rev. 22.18). It also compre­hendeth all the great and signal events of Providence, re­lating either to the Christian Church, or to its Antichri­stian Enemies, in the several Periods of time, to the end of the World (Rev. 1.19)—all which the Spirit of God discovers to us, in the opening of the seven Seals, the sounding of the seven Trumpets, and the pouring out of the seven Vials.

The first five Seals express the state of the Church under the bloody persecuting Heathen Emperors.

Seal 1.

The first Seal opened (Rev. 9.2), gives the Church a very encouraging and comfortable prospect of the Victories, Suc­cesses, and Triumphs of Christ, notwithstanding the rage, subtlety, and power of all its Enemies. He shall ride on Conquering, and to Conquer; and his Arrows shall be sharp in the Hearts of his Enemies, whereby the People shall fall under him. And this cheering Prospect was no more than was needful. For

Seal 2.

The second Seal opened (Rev. 9.3-4), represents the first bloody Persecution of the Church under Nero, whom Tertullian calls Dedicator damnationis nostrae: He that first con­demned Christians to the Slaughter. And the Perse­cution under him, is set forth by the Type of a red Horse, and a great Sword in the hand of him that rode thereon. His cruelty is by Paul compared to the mouth of a Lion. 2 Tim. 4.17. Paul, Peter, Bartholomew, Barnabas, Mark, are all said to die by his cruel hand: and so fierce was his rage against the Christians, that at that time, as Eusebius saith, a man might then see Cities lie full of dead Bodies, the old and young, men and women cast out naked, without any reverence of persons or sex, in the open street. And when the day failed, Christians (saith Tacitus) were burnt in the night, instead of Torches, to give them light in the Streets.

Seal 3.

The third Seal opened (Rev. 9.5-6), sets forth the calamities which should befall the Church by Famine. Yet not so much a literal as a figurative Famine, as a grave and learned Com­mentator (Durham in loc.) expounds it, like that mentioned in Amos 8.11-12, which fell out under Maximinus, and Trajan. The for­mer directing the Persecution, especially against Ministers, in which, many bright Lamps were extinguished. The latter expressly condemned all Christian Meetings and Assemblies by a Law. The Type by which this Persecu­tion was set forth, is a black Horse. A gloomy and dis­mal day it was indeed to the poor Saints, when they eat the bread of their Souls, as it were by weight, for he that sat on him, had a pair of balances in his hand. Then did John hear this sad voice, A measure of wheat for a Penny, and three measures of Barley for a penny. That quantity was but the ordinary allowance, to keep a man alive for a day. And a Roman Penny was the ordinary wages given for a day’s work to a labourer. The meaning is, that in those days, all the Spiritual food men should get, to keep their Souls alive from day to day, with all their travel and labour, should be but sufficient for that end.

Seal 4.

The fourth Seal opened (Rev. 9.7-8), represents a much more sad and doleful state of the Church: for under it are found all the former sufferings, with some new kinds of trouble superadded. Under this Seal, death rides upon the pale Horse, and Hell, or the Grave follows him. ‘Tis con­ceived to point at the persecution under Diocletian, when the Church was mowed down as a Meadow.

Seal 5.

The fifth Seal is opened in my Text, under which the Lord Jesus represents to his servant John the state and condition of those precious Souls, which had been torn and separated from their Bodies, by the bloody hands of Tyrants, for his name sake, under all the former persecutions. The design whereof is, to support and encourage all that were to come after, in the same bloody path. “I saw under the Altar,” &c. in which we have an account,

I. Of what John saw.
II. Of what he heard.

I. What John saw.

I. First we have an account of what he saw, “I saw the Souls of them that were slain for the word of God, and for the testimony which they held.

Souls in this place are not put for the Blood, or the dead Carcasses of the Saints, who were slain, as some have groundlessly imagined; but are to be understood properly and strictly, for those Spiritual and immortal substances, which once had a vital Union with their Bo­dies, but were now separated from them by a violent death; yet still retained a love and inclination to them, even in the state of Separation, and are therefore here brought in complaining of their shedding of their blood, and destruction of their Bodies.

These Souls (even of all that died for Christ, from Abel, to that time) John saw, that is, in Spirit; for these immaterial substances are not perceptible by the gross external senses. He had the privilege and favour of a Spiritual representation of them, being therein extraordina­rily assisted, as Paul was when his Soul was rapt into the third Heaven, and heard things unutterable, 2 Cor. 12.2. God gave him a transient visible representation of those holy Souls, and that under the Altar, he means not any ma­terial Altar, as that at Jerusalem was; but as the holy place figured Heaven, so the Altar figured Jesus Christ, Heb. 13.10. And most aptly Christ is represented to John in this figure, and Souls of the Martyrs at the foot or basis of this Altar, thereby to inform us (1) that however men look upon the death of those persons, and though they kill their names by slanders, as well as their persons by the Sword; yet in God’s account, they die as Sacrifices, and their blood is no other than a drink-offering poured out to God, which he highly prizeth, and graciously accepteth. Suitable whereunto Paul’s expression is, Philip. 2.17. (2) That the value and acceptation their death and blood shed hath with God, is through Christ, and upon his account; for it is the Altar which sanctifieth the gift. Mat. 23.19. and (3.) it informs us that these holy Souls, now in a state of Separation from their Bodies, were very near to Jesus Christ in Heaven. They lay as it were at his foot.

Once more, They are here described to us, by the cause of their sufferings and death in this World, and that was, “For the word of God, and for the Testimony which they held.” (i.e.) They died in defence of the Truths, or will of God revealed in his word, against the Corruptions, Oppositions, and Innovations of Men. As one of the Martyrs, that held up the Bible at the Stake, saying, This is it that hath brought me hither. They died not as Malefactors, but as Witnesses. They gave a threefold Testimony to the truth: a lip Testimony, a life Testimony, and a blood Testimony; whilst the Hypocrite gives but one, and many Christians but two. Thus we have an account of what John saw.

II. What John heard.

II. Next he tells us what he heard, and that was,

1. A vehement cry from those Souls to God.
2. A gracious Answer from God to them.

1. The cry which they uttered with a loud voice was this, “How long, O Lord, Holy, and True, dost thou not avenge our blood on them that dwell on the Earth?” A cry like that from the blood of Abel. Yet let it be remembered: (1) This cry doth not imply these holy Souls to be in a restless state, or to want true satisfaction and repose out of the Body. Nor yet (2) that they carried with them to Heaven any ma­levolent or revengeful disposition; but that which is prin­cipally signified by this Cry, is their vehement desire af­ter the abolition of the Kingdom of Satan, and the Com­pletion and Consummation of Christ’s Kingdom in this World. That those his Enemies which oppose his King­dom, by slaying his Saints, may be made his footstool, which is the same thing Christ waits for in glory, Heb. 10.13.

2. Secondly, Here we find God’s gracious Answer to the cry of these Souls, in which he speaks satisfaction to them two ways:

(1.) By somewhat given them for present.
(2.) By somewhat promised them hereafter.

(1.) That which he gives them in hand, “White Robes were given to every one of them.” It is generally agreed, that these white Robes given them, denote heavenly Glory, the same which is promised to all sincere and faithful ones, who preserve themselves pure from the corruptions and defilements of the World, Rev. 3.4. and it is as much as if God should have said to them, Although the time be not come to satisfy your desires in the final ruine and over­throw of Satan’s Tyrannical Kingdom in the World, and Christ’s consummate Conquest of all his Enemies, yet it shall be well with you in the mean time, you shall “walk with me in white, and enjoy your glory in Heaven.

(2.) And this is not all, but the very things they cry for, shall be given them also after a little season, q.d. wait but a little while, till the rest that are to follow in the same suffer­ing path, be got through the Red Sea of Martyrdom, as you are, and then you shall see the foot of Christ upon the necks of all his Enemies, and justice shall fully avenge the pre­cious innocent blood of all the Saints, which in all Ages hath been shed for my sake; from the blood of Abel, to the last that shall ever suffer for Righteousness sake in the World. From all which this Conclusion is most fair and obvious:


That the Souls of men perish not with their Bodies, but do cer­tainly over-live them, and subsist in a state of separation from them. “Fear not them that kill the Body, but are not able to kill the Soul.” (Mat. 10.28).

The Bodies of these Martyrs of Jesus were destroyed by divers sorts of torments, but their Souls were out of the reach of all those cruel Engines. They were in safety under the Altar, and in glory, clothed with their white Robes, when the Bodies they lately inhabited on earth, were turned to ashes, and torn to pieces by wild Beasts.

The point I am to discourse from this Scripture, is the immortality of the Soul, for the better understanding whereof, let it be noted that there is a twofold Immortality.

I. Simple and absolute in its own Nature.
II. Derived, dependent, and from the pleasure of God.

In the former Sense, God only hath Immortality, as the Apostle speaks (1 Tim. 6.16); our Souls have it as a gift from him. He that created our Souls out of nothing, can, if he please, reduce them to nothing again. But he hath bestowed Immortality upon them, and produced them in a nature suitable to that his appointment: fitted for an everlasting life. So that, though God by his absolute power can—yet he never will—annihilate them, but they shall and must live for ever in endless Blessedness or Misery. Death must de­stroy these mortal Bodies, but it cannot destroy our Souls. And the certainty of this assertion is grounded upon these reasons, and will be cleared by these following Argu­ments.

Argument I.

The first Argument for proof of the Soul’s Immortality, may be taken from the Simplicity, Spirituality, and uncompoundedness of its Nature. It is a pure, simple, un­mixed being. Death is the dissolution of things com­pounded; where therefore no composition or mixture is found, no death or dissolution can follow.

Death is the great Divider, but it is of things that are divisible. The more simple, pure and refined any material thing is, by so much the more permanent and durable it is found to be. The nearer it approacheth to the nature of Spi­rits, the farther it is removed from the power of death: but that which is not material, or mixed at all, is wholly exempt from the stroke and power of death. It is from the contrariant qualities and jarring humours in mixed Bodies, that they come under the Law and power of dissolution. Matter and Mixture are the doors at which death enters naturally upon the Creatures.

But the Soul of man is a simple, spiritual, immaterial, and unmixed Being, not compounded of matter and form, as other Creatures are, but void of matter, and altogether Spiritual: as may appear in the vast capacity of its understanding faculty, which cannot be straightened by receiving multitudes of Truths into it. It need not empty itself of what it had received before, to make way for more truth; nor doth it find itself clogged or burthened by the greatest multitudes or varieties of Truths, but the more it knows, the more it still desires to know. Its capacity and appetite are found to enlarge themselves according to the increase of knowledge. So that to speak as the matter is, if the Knowledge of all Arts, Sciences, and Mysteries of Nature could be gathered into the mind of one man; yet that mind would thirst, and even burn with desire after more knowledge, and find more room for it than it did when it first sipt and relished the sweetness of truth. Knowledge, as Knowledge, never burthens or cloys the mind; but like fire increases and enlarges, as it finds more matter to work upon. Now, this could never be, if the Soul were a material Being. Take the largest Vessel, and you shall find that the more you pour into it, the less room is still left for more; and when it is full, you cannot pour in one drop more, except you let out what was in it before. But the Soul is no such Vessel, it can retain all it had, and be still receptive of more; so that nothing can fill it and satisfy it, but that which is infinite and perfect.

The natural appetite after food is sometimes sharp and eager, but then there is a stint and measure, beyond which it craves not; but the appetite of the mind is more eager and unlimited, it never saith, till it come to rest in God, “it is enough,” because the faculty which produceth it, is more active, spiritual and immaterial. All matter hath its limits, bounds, and just measures, beyond which it cannot be ex­tended. But the Soul is boundless, and its appetitions in­finite; is rests not, but in the spiritual and infinite Be­ing, God alone being is adequate object, and able to satisfy its desires: which plainly proves it to be a Spiri­tual immaterial, and simple being. And being so, two things necessarily follow therefrom.

1. That it is void of any Principle of corruption in itself.
2. That it is not liable to any stroke of death, by any ad­verse power without itself.

1. It cannot be liable to death, from any seeds or Prin­ciples of Corruption within itself, for where there is no composition, there is no dissolution, the Spirituality and simplicity of the Soul admits of no Corruption.

2. Nor is it liable to death, by any adverse power with­out itself. No Sword can touch it. No instrument of death can reach it. ‘Tis above the reach of all adversaries, Matt. 10.28. “Fear not them that can kill the Body, but cannot kill the Soul.” The bounds and limits of creature-power are here fixed by Jesus Christ, beyond which they cannot go. They can wound, torment, and destroy the Body, when God permits them: but the Soul is out of their reach. A Sword can no more wound it, than it can wound or hurt the light, and consequently it is, and must needs be of an immortal nature.


But there seems to be a decay upon our Souls in our old Age, and decays argue and imply corruption and are so many steps and tendencies towards the death and dissolution there­of. The experience of the whole world shews us how the Apprehensions, Judgments, Wit, and Memory of old Men fail, even to that degree, that they become children again in respect of the abilities of their minds: their Souls only serving as it were to salt their Bodies, and keep them from putrefaction for a few days longer.


‘Tis a great mistake, there is not the least decay upon the Soul, no time makes any change upon the essence of the Soul: all the alteration that is made, is upon the Organs and Instruments of the Body which decay in time, and be­come inept and unserviceable to the Soul.

The Soul like an expert and skilful Musician is as able as ever it was, but the Body its instrument is out of tune, and the ablest Artist can make no pleasing melody upon an in­strument whose Strings are broken, or so related that they cannot be screwed up to their due height.

Let Hippocrates the Prince of Physicians decide this mat­ter for us. “The Soul (saith he) can­not be changed or altered as to its es­sence by the access of meat or drink, or any other thing whatsoever; but all the alterations that are made, must be re­ferred either to the Spirits with which it mixeth itself, or to the Vessels and Or­gans through which it streameth.” (lib. 1, de diaeta.). So that this proves not its corruptibility: and being neither corruptible in itself, nor vulnerable by any creature without itself; seeing man cannot, and God will not destroy it: the conclusion is strongly inferred, that there­fore it is immortal.

Argument II.

The Immortality of the Souls of Men may be concluded from the Promises of everlasting Blessedness, and the Threatnings of everlasting miseries respectively made in the Scriptures of truth, to the Godly and ungodly, after this Life; which Promises and Threatnings had been altogether vain and delusory, if our Souls perish with our Bodies.

1. Eternal blessedness for the godly.

1. First, God hath made many everlasting Promises of Bles­sedness, yea he hath established an everlasting Covenant, betwixt himself and the Souls of the Righteous; promi­sing to be their God for ever, and to bestow endless Bles­sedness upon them in the World to come. Such a Pro­mise is that, John 8.28. “I give unto them eternal life, and they shall never perish.” And John 4.14. “Whosoever drinketh of the Water that I shall give him, shall never thirst; but the Water that I shall give him, shall be in him a Well of Water, spring­ing up into everlasting life.” And again, John 11.26. “Whosoe­ver liveth and believeth in me, shall never die.” And once more, Rom. 2.7. “To them who by patient continuance in well doing, seek for Glory and Honour, and Immortality, eternal Life”—with mul­titudes more of like nature.

Now if these be no vain and delusory Promises, (as to be sure they are not, being the words of the true and faith­ful God) then those Souls to whom they are made, must live for ever; for if the subject of the Promises must fail, con­sequently the performance of the Promises must fail too. For how shall they be made good, when those to whom they are made, are perished?

Let it not be objected here, That the Bodies of Belie­vers are concerned in the promises, as well as their Souls, and yet their Bodies perish, notwithstanding.

For we say, though their Bodies die, yet they shall live again, and enjoy the fruit of the Promises in eternal Glory: And whilst their Bodies lie in the Grave, their Souls are with God, enjoying the covenanted Blessedness in Heaven, Rom. 8.10-11. and so the Covenant-Bond is not loosed betwixt them and God, by Death, which it must needs be, in case the Soul perished when the Body doth. And upon this Hypothesis that Argument of Christ is built, Mat. 22.32. proving the Resurrection from the Cove­nant God made with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. “I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. God is not the God of the Dead, but of the Living.” q.d. If A­braham, Isaac, and Jacob, be perished in Soul as well as in Body, how then is God their God? What is become of the Promise and Covenant-Relation? For if one Correlate fail, the Relation necessarily fails with it. If God be their God, then certainly they are in being; for God is not the God of the Dead, (i.e.) of those that are utterly perish­ed. Therefore it must needs be, that though their Bodies be naturally dead, yet their Souls still live; and their Bodies must live again at the Resurrection, by virtue of the same Promise.

2. Eternal misery for the ungodly.

2. On the contrary, many threatnings of eternal misery af­ter this life, are found in the Scriptures of truth, against ungodly and wicked Persons. Such is that in 2 Thes. 1.7-9. “The Lord Jesus Christ, who shall be revealed from Heaven in flaming Fire, to render Vengeance on them that know not God, and that obey not the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ, who shall be punished with ever­lasting Destruction, from the presence of the Lord, and the Glory of his Power.” And speaking of the Torments of the Dam­ned, Christ thus expresseth the misery of such wretched Souls in Hell, Mark 9.44. “Where their Worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched.” But how shall the Wicked be pu­nished with everlasting Destruction, if their Souls have not an everlasting Duration? Or how can it be said, “That their Worm (viz. the remorse and anguish of their Consciences) dieth not,” if their Souls die? Punishment can endure no longer than its subject endureth. If the being of the Soul cease, its pains and punishments must have an end.

You see then, there are everlasting Promises and Threatenings to be fulfilled, both upon the Godly and Ungodly. “He that believeth on the Son, hath everlasting life; and he that believeth not the Son, shall not see Life, but the wrath of God abideth on him, John 3.36. The Believer shall never see spiritual Death, viz. the separation of his Soul from God; and the Unbeliever shall never see life, viz. the blessed fru­ition of God; but the Wrath of God shall abide on him. If Wrath must abide on him, he must abide also as the wretched subject thereof, which is another Argument of the Immortality of Souls.

Argument III.

The Immortality of the Soul is a Truth asserted and attested by the universal consent of all Nations and Ages of the World. “We give much (saith Seneca) to the presumption of all men,” and that justly; for it would be hard to think that an Error should obtain the general consent of Mankind, or that God would suffer all the World, in all Ages of it, to bow down under an universal Deception.

This Doctrine sticks close to the nature of Man; it springs up easily, and without force from his Conscience. It hath been allowed as an unquestionable thing, not only among Christians, who have the Oracles of God to teach and confirm this Doctrine, but among Heathens also, who had no other Light but that of Nature, to guide them in­to the knowledge and belief of it. Learned Zanchius cites out of Cicero an excellent passage to this purpose: “In every thing (saith he) the consent of all Nations is to be accounted the Law of Nature.” And therefore with all good Men it should be instead of a thousand Demonstrations: and to resist it, (as he there adds) what is it, but to resist the voice of God? and how much more, when with this consent the Word of God doth also consent? As for the consent of Nations in this point, the learned Author last mentioned hath industriously gathered many great and famous Testi­monies from the ancient Chaldeans, Graecians, Pythagoreans, Stoicks, Platonists, &c. which evidently shew they made no doubt of the Immortality of their Souls. How plain is that [saying] of Phocylides? Speaking of the Soul, in opposition to the Body, which must be resolved into dust, he saith, “But for the Soul, that is immortal, and never grows old, but lives for ever.

And Trisme­gistus, the famous and celebrated Philosopher, gives this ac­count of Man, that he consists of two parts, being mortal in respect of his Body, but immortal in respect of his Soul; which is his best and principal part. Pluto not only asserts the immortality of the Souls of Men, but disputes for it, and among other Arguments urges this, “That if it were not so, wicked Men would certainly have the advantage of righteous and good Men, who after they have committed all manner of evils, should suffer none.” But what speak I of Philosophers? The most barbarous Nations in the World constantly believe it. The Turks acknowledge it in their Koran; and though they grossly mistake the nature of Heaven, in fancying it to be a Paradise of sensual Pleasures, as well as the way thither; by their Impostor Muhammad; yet ’tis plain they believe the Soul’s immortality, and that it lives in pain or pleasure after this life.

The very savage and illiterate Indians are so fully persua­ded of the Soul’s Immortality, that Wives cast themselves cheerfully into the Flames to attend the Souls of their Hus­bands; and Subjects, to attend the Souls of their Kings, into the other World.

Two things are objected against this Argument.

Objection. 1.

I. That some particular persons have denied this Do­ctrine, as Epicurus, &c. and by Argument maintained the contrary.


To which I answer, That though they have done so, yet (1.) this no way shakes the Argument from the con­sent of Nations, because some few persons have denied it: we truly say the Earth is Spherical, though there be many Hills and Risings in it. If Democritus put out his own eyes, must we therefore say all the World is blind?

(2.) It is worth thinking on, whether they that have que­stioned the Immortality of the Soul, have not rather made it the matter of their option and desire, than of their Faith and Persuasion. We distinguish Atheists into three Classes, such as are so in Practice, in Desire, or in Judgment; but of the former sorts there may be found multitudes, to one that is so in his settled judgment. If you think it strange that any Man should wish his Soul to be mortal, Hierocles gives us the true reason of it, “A wicked man (saith he) is afraid of his Judge, and therefore wishes his Soul and Body may perish toge­ther by Death, rather than it should come to God’s Tribunal.

Objection. 2.

II. Nor can the strength of the Argument be eluded by saying, All this may be but an universal Tradition, one Nation receiving it from another.


For as this is neither true in itself, nor possible to be made good, so if it were, it would not invalidate the Argument; for if it were not a truth agreeable to the light of nature, and so easily received by all Men upon the Proposal of it, it were impossible that all Nations in the World should embrace it so readily, and hold it so tenaciously as they do.

Argument IV.

The Immortality of the Soul may be evinced from the everlasting habits which are subjected and inherent in it. If these habits abide for ever, certainly so must the Souls in which they are planted.

The Souls of good Men are the good Ground, in which the Seed of Grace is sown by the Spirit (Mat. 13.23), (i.e) the subjects in which gracious properties and affe­ctions do inhere and dwell, (which is the formal notion of a Substance) and these implanted Graces are everlasting things. So, John 4.14. “It shall be in him a Well of Water, spring­ing up into everlasting Life, (i.e.) the Graces of the Spirit shall be in Believers permanent habits, fixed Principles, which shall never decay. And therefore that Seed of Grace which is cast into their Souls at their Regeneration, is in 1 Pet. 1.23. called “incorruptible Seed, which liveth and abideth for ever: and it is incorruptible, not only considered abstractly, in its own simple nature, but concretely, as it is in the san­ctified Soul, its Subject; for it is said, 1 John 3.9. “The Seed of God remaineth in him.” It abideth for ever in the Soul. If then these two things be clear to us, viz.

1. That the Habits of Grace be everlasting.
2. That they are inseparable from sanctified Souls;

It must needs follow that the Soul, their Subject, is so too, an everlasting and immortal Soul. And how plainly do both these Propositions lie before us in the Scriptures? As for the immortal and interminable nature of saving Grace, it is plain to him that considers, not only what the fore cited Scriptures speak about it, calling it “incorruptible Seed, a Well of Water springing up into everlasting life.” But add to these what is said of these Divine qualities, in 2 Pet. 1.4. where they are called the Divine Nature: and Ephes. 4.18. “The life of God,” noting the perpetuity of these Principles in Believers, as well as their resemblance of God in Holiness, who are endowed with them.

I know it is a great question among Divines, An gratia in renatis sit naturà & essentià suà interminabilis? Whether these Principles of Grace in the Regenerate be everlasting and interminable in their own nature and essence? For my own part I think that God only is naturally, essentially, and absolutely interminable and immortal. But these gracious Habits, planted by him in the Soul, are so by virtue of God’s Appointment, Promise and Covenant. And sure it is that by reason hereof they are interminate, which is e­nough for my purpose, if they be not essentially intermi­nable. Though Grace be but a Creature, and therefore hath a pesse mori, yet it is a Creature begotten by the Word and Spirit of God, which live and abide for ever, and a Creature within the Promise and Covenant of God, by reason whereof it can never actually die.

And then, as for the inseparableness of these Graces from the Souls in whom they are planted, how clear is this from 1 John 2.27. where sanctifying Grace is compared to an Unction, and this Unction is said to abide in them: And 1 John 3.9. ’tis called the Seed of God, which remaineth in the Soul. All our natural and moral Excellencies and Endowments go away when we die, Job 4.21. “Doth not their Excellency that is in them go away?” Men may out-live their acquired Gifts, but not their supernatural Graces: These stick by the Soul as Ruth to Naomi, and where it goes, they go too; so that when the Soul is dislodged by Death, all its Graces ascend up with it into Glory: it carries away all its Faith, Love, Delight in God, all its comfortable ex­periences, and fruits of Communion with God, along with it to Heaven. For Death is so far from divesting the Soul of its Graces, that it perfects in a Moment all that was de­fective in them; 1 Cor. 13.10. “When that which is perfect shall come, then that which is in part shall be done away,” as the Twi­light is done away when the Sun is up, and at its Zenith. So then, Grace never dieth, and this never-dying Grace is inseparable from its Subject; by which it is plain to him that considers, That as Graces, so Souls abide for ever.


But this only proves the Immortality of regenerate Souls.


It doth so, but then consider, as there be gracious habits in the regenerate that never die; so there are vicious habits in the unregenerate, that can never be separated from them in the world to come. Hence John 8.21. They are said to “die in their sins,” and Job 20.11. “Their iniquities lie down with them in the dust,” and Ezek. 24.13. “They shall never be purged.” Remarkable is that place, Rev. 22.11. “Let him that is filthy, be filthy still.” And if guilt stick so fast, and sin be so deeply engraven in impenitent Souls, they also must remain for ever, to bear the punishment of them.

Argument V.

The Immortality of the Soul of Man may be evinced from the Dignity of Man above all other Creatures (Angels only excepted) and his Dominion over them all.

In this the Scriptures are clear, that Man is the Masterpiece of all God’s other work, Psal. 8.5-6. “For thou hast made him a little lower than the Angels and hast crowned him with glory and honour. Thou hast made him to have Dominion over the works of thy hands, thou hast put all things under his feet.” Other Creatures were made for his service, and he is crowned King over them all. One Man is of more worth than all the inferiour Creatures.

But wherein is his Dignity and excellency above all o­ther Creatures, if not in respect of the capacity and immor­tality of his Soul? Sure it can be found nowhere else, for as to the Body, many of the Creatures excel man in the perfections of Sense, greatness of Strength, agility of Mem­bers, &c. Nos Aper auditu praecellit, aranea tactu, vultur odo­ratu, linx visu, simia gustu: And for beauty, “Solomon in all his Glory was not arrayed like one of the Lilies of the Field.” The Beasts, and Fowls enjoy more pleasure, and live dive­sted of those cares and cumbers which perplex and wear out the lives of men. It cannot be in respect of bodily per­fections or pleasures that man excels other Creatures.

If you say, he excels them all in respect of that noble endowment of Reason, which is peculiar to man, and his sin­gular excellency above them all.

‘Tis true, this is his glory, but if you deprive the reaso­nable Soul of Immortality, you despoil it of all, both its glory and comfort, and put the reasonable into a worse condition than the unreasonable and brutish Creatures. For if the Soul may die with the Body, and man perish as the Beast, happier is the life of the Beast, which is perplexed with no cares nor fears about futurities: our Reason serves to little other purpose, but to be an engine of Torture, a meer Rack to our Souls.

Certainly, the Privilege of Man doth not consist in that, as abstracted from Immortality. But in this it pro­perly consists, that he enjoys not only a reasonable, but al­so rejoiceth in an Immortal Soul, which shall overlive the world, and subsist separate from the Body, and abide for ever, when all other Souls being but material forms, pe­rish with that matter on which they depend. This is the proper Dignity of Man above the Beast that perisheth, and to deprive him of Immortality, and leave him his Reason, is but to leave him a more miserable and wretched Creature than any that God hath put under his feet. For Man is a prospecting Creature, and raiseth up to himself vast hopes and fears from the world to come: by these he is restrained from the sensual pleasures which other Creatures freely enjoy, and exercised with ten thousands cares which they are unacquainted with; and to fail at last of all his hopes and expectations of happiness in the world to come, is to fall many degrees lower than the lowest Creature shall fall, even so much lower, as his expectations and hopes had lifted him higher.

Argument VI.

The Souls of Men must be Immortal, or else the de­sires of Immortality are planted in their Souls in vain.

That there are desires of Immortality found in the hearts of all men, is a truth too evident to be denied or doubted. Man cannot bound and terminate his de­sires within the narrow limits of this world, and the time that measures it. Nothing that can be measured by time, is commensurate to the desires of Man’s Soul. No Motto better suits it than this, Non est mortale quod opto. I seek for that which will not die. Rom. 2.7. and his great relief against death lies in this, Non omnis moriar: That he shall not to­tally perish. Yea we find in all men, even in those that seem to be most drowned and lost in the loves and delights of this present World, a natural desire to continue their Names and Memories to posterity after death. Hence it is said, Psal. 49.11. “Their inward thought is that their houses shall continue for ever, and their dwelling-places to all generations, they call their lands after their own Names.”

“I beseech men for God’s sake that if at any time there arise in them a desire, or a wish that others should speak well of them rather than evil after their death, then at that time they would seriously consider whe­ther those motions are not from some Spirit to continue a Spirit af­ter it leaves its earthly habitation, rather than from an earthly Spirit, a vapour, which cannot act, or ima­gine, or desire, or fear things be­yond its continuance. (Hale de A­nim. p. 73).

And hence is the desire of children, which is, as one saith, nodosa Aeternitas, a knotty Aeternity, when our thread is spun out and cut off, their thread is knit to it: and so we dream of a continued succession in our Name and Fami­ly.

Absalom had no children to continue his Memory, to sup­ply which defect, he reared up a Pillar, 2 Sam. 18.18. Now it cannot be imagined, that God should plant the desire of Immortality in those Souls that are incapable of it; nor yet can we give a rational account, how these ap­prehensions of Immortality should come into the Souls of men, except they themselves be of an immortal nature. For, either these notions and apprehensions of Immortality, are imprest upon our Souls by God, or do na­turally spring out of the Souls of men: if God impress them, those impressions are made in vain, if there be no such thing as Immortality to be enjoyed; and if they spring and rise naturally out of our Souls, that is a sufficient evidence of their Immortality. For we cannot more con­ceive and form to ourselves Ideas and Notions of Immortality, if our Souls be mortal, than the Brutes which are void of reason, can form to themselves Notions and Conceptions of rationality. So then, the very apprehen­sions and desires that are found in men’s hearts of Immorta­lity, do plainly speak them to be of an Immortal Nature.

Argument VII.

Moreover, the account given us in Scripture of the re­turn of several Souls into their own Bodies again after death, and real separation from them, shews us that the Soul subsists and lives in a separate state after death, and perisheth not by the stroke of death. For if it were annihila­ted or destroyed by death, the same Soul could never be re­stored again to the same Body.

A dead Body may indeed be acted by an assisting form, which may move and carry it from place to place. So the Devil hath acted the dead Bo­dies of many; but they cannot be said to live again, by their own Souls, after a real separation by death, unless those Souls over-lived the Bodies they forsook at death, and had their abode in another Place and state. You have divers unquestionable examples of the Soul’s return into the Body recorded in Scripture. As that of the Shunamite’s Son, 2 Kings 4.18-20, 32-37. That of the Ruler’s daughter, Mat. 9.18, 23-25. That of the Widow’s Son, Luke 7.12-15. and that of Lazarus, John 11.39-45. These were no other but the very same Souls, their own Souls which returned into them again, which as Chrysostom well observes, is a great proof of their Immortality, against them that think the Soul is annihilated after the death of the Body.

‘Tis true, the Scripture gives us no account of any sense or apprehension they retained after their reunion, of the place or state they were in, during their separation. There seemed to be perfect άμνησία, forgetfulness of all that they saw or felt in the state of separation. And indeed it was necessary it should be so, that our faith might be built rather upon the sure promises of God, than such reports and narratives of them that came to us from the dead, Luke 16.31. And if we believe not the word, neither would we believe, if one came from the dead.

Argument VIII.

Moreover eighthly, The supposition of the Souls perishing with the Body, is subversive of the Christian Religion, in the principal Doctrines and Duties thereof. Take away the Immortality of the Soul, and all Religion falls to the ground. I will instance in:

I. The Doctrines of Religion.
II. The Duties of Religion.

I. Annihilationism overthrows the principal doctrines of religion.

First, It overthrows the main Principles and Doctrines of Christian Religion, upon which both our faith and com­fort is founded; and consequently, it undoes and ruins us, as to all solid hope and true joy. The Doctrines or Princi­ples it overthrows are among many others such as follow:

1. Election.

1. It nullifies and makes void the great design and end of God’s eternal Election. The Scriptures tell us that from eternity God hath chosen a certain number in Christ Jesus, to eternal life, and to the means by which they shall attain it: out of his mere good pleasure, and for the praise of his grace. This was (1) an eternal Act of God, Eph. 1.4. long before we had our being, Rom. 9.11. (2) This choice of God, or his purpose to save some, is immutable, 2 Tim. 2.19. James 1.17. (3) This choice he made in Christ, Eph. 1.4. Not that Christ is the cause of God’s choosing us: For we were not elected, because we were, but that we might be in Christ. Christ was ordained to be the Medium of the execution of this Decree: and all the mercies which were purposed and ordained for us, were to be pur­chased by the blood of Christ He was not the cause of the Decree, but the purchaser of the mercies decreed for us. (4) This choice was of a certain number of persons, who are all known to God, 2 Tim. 2.19. and all given to Christ in the Covenant of Redemption, John 17.2, 6. So that no Elect per­son can be a Reprobate, no Reprobate an Elect person. (5) This number was chosen to Salvation, 1 Thes. 5.9. No less did God design for them than glory and happiness, and that for ever. (6) The same persons that are appointed to Salvation as the end, are also appointed to sanctification, as the way and means, by which they shall attain that end. 1 Pet. 1.1-2; 2 Thes. 2.13-14. (7) The impulsive cause of this choice was, the mere good pleasure of his will. 2. Tim. 1.9. Rom. 9.15-16. Ephes. 1.9. (8) The end of all this is, the praise of his glorious grace, Eph. 1.5-6. to make a glori­ous Manifestation of the riches of his grace for ever. This is the account the Scripture give us of God’s eternal choice.

But if our Souls be mortal, and perish with our Bodies, all this is a mistake, and we are imposed upon, and our un­derstandings abused by this Doctrine. For to what purpose are all these Decrees and contrivances of God from ever­lasting, if our Souls perish with our Bodies? Certainly, if it be so, he loseth all the thoughts and counsels of his heart about us, and that counsel of his will which is so much ce­lebrated in the Scriptures, and admired by his People comes to nought. For this is evident to every mans consideration, that if the Soul (which is the Object, about which all those counsels and thoughts of God were employed and laid out) fail in its being, all those thoughts and counsels that have been employed about it, and spent on it, must necessarily fail, and come to nothing with it. The thoughts of his heart cannot stand fast, as it is said Psal. 33.11. if the Soul slide, about which they are conversant. In that day the elect Soul perisheth, the eternal consultations and purposes of God’s heart perish with it. Kekerman tells us that Albertus Magnus with abundance of Art, and the study of thirty years made a vocal Statue in the form of a Man. It was a rare con­trivance, and much admired. The cunning Artist had so framed it, that by Wheels and other Machines placed within it, it could pronounce words articulately. A­quinas being surprised to hear the Statue speak, was affright­ed at it, and brake it all to pieces. Upon which Albertus told him, he had at one blow destroyed the work of thirty years. Such a blow would the death of the Soul give to the counsels and thoughts not of Man, but of God, not of thirty years, but from everlasting.

If the Souls of men perish at death, either God never did appoint any Souls to Salvation, as the Scriptures testify he did, 1 Thes. 5.9. or else the foundation of God stands not sure, as his word tells us, it doth, 2 Tim. 2.19. So then, this supposition overturns the eternal Decrees and Counsels of God, which is the first thing.

2. The Covenant of Redemption.

2. It overthrows the Covenant of Redemption betwixt the Father and the Son, before this World was made. There was a federal transaction betwixt the Father and Son from Eternity, about our Salvation, 2 Tim. 1.9; Zech. 6.13. In that Covenant Christ engaged to redeem the Elect by his blood. And the Father promised him a reward of those his sufferings, Isa. 53.12. accordingly he hath poured out his Soul to death for them, finished the work, John 17.4. and is now in Heaven, expecting the full reward and fruits of his sufferings, which consist not in his own personal glory, which he there enjoys, but in the completeness and fullness of his mystical Body, John 17.24.

But certainly, if our Souls perish with our Bodies, Christ hath a very bad bargain of it. Nor can that promise be ever made good to him, Isa. 53.12. He shall see of the travel of his Soul, and be satisfied. He hath done his work, but where is his reward? See how this supposition strikes at the justice of God, and wounds his faithfulness, in his Covenant with his Son. He hath as much comfort and re­ward from the travail of his Soul, as a Mother that is deli­vered after many sharp pangs of a Child that dies almost as soon as born.

3. The work of Christ.

3. It overthrows the Doctrines of Christ’s Incarnation, Death, Resurrection, Ascension, and Intercession in Heaven for us. And these are the main Pillars both of our faith and comfort; take away these, and take away our lives too, for these are the springs of all joy and comfort to the people of God, Rom. 8.34

His Incarnation was necessary to capacitate him for his Me­diatorial work. It was not only a part of it, but such a part, without which he could discharge no other part of it. This was the wonder of men and Angels, 1 Tim. 3.16. A God incarnate is the World’s wonder. No condescension like this, Philip. 2 6-7.

The Death of Christ hath the nature and respect of a Ransom, or equivalent price laid down to the justice of God for our Redemption, Matt. 20.28; Act. 20.28. It bought our Souls from under the curse, and purchased for them everlasting Blessedness, Galat. 4.4-5.

The Resurrection of Christ from the Dead, hath the nature both of a Testimony of his finishing the work of our Re­demption, and the Fathers full satisfaction therein, John 6.10. and of a Principle of our Resurrection to eternal life, 1 Cor. 15.20.

The Ascension of Christ into Heaven, was in the capacity and relation of a forerunner, Heb. 6.20. It was to prepare places for the redeemed, who were to come after him to glory in their several generations, John 14.2-3.

The Intercession of Christ in Heaven, is for the security of our purchased inheritance, to us, and to prevent any new breaches which might be made by our Sins, whereby it might be forfeited, and we divested of it again, 1 John 2.1-2.

All these jointly make up the foundation of our faith and hope of glory. But if our Souls perish, or be annihi­lated at death, our Faith, Hope, and Comforts are all Delu­sions, vain Dreams which do but abuse our fond Imagina­tions. For

(1.) It was not worth so great a stoop and abasement of the blessed God, as he submitted to, in his Incarnation, wherein he appeared in flesh, yea, in the likeness of sinful flesh, Rom. 8.3. and made himself of no reputation, Philip. 2.7. An act that is, and ever will be admired by men and An­gels: I say, it was not worth so great a Miracle as this, to procure for us the vanishing comfort of a few years, and that short-lived comfort, no other than a deluding Dream, or mocking Phantasm; For seeing it consists in hope and ex­pectation from the world to come, as the Scriptures every where speak, 1 Thes. 5.8; 2 Cor. 3.12; Rom. 5.3-5. if there be no such enjoyments for us there, (as most certain­ly there are not, if our Souls perish) it is but a vanity, a thing of nought, that was the errand upon which the Son of God came from the father’s bosom, to procure for us.

(2) And for what think you was the blood of God upon the Cross? what was so vast and inconceivable a treasure expended to purchase? What! the flattering and vain hopes of a few years, of which we may say, as it was said of the Roman Consulship, unius anni volaticum gaudium: the fugitive joy of a year, yea, not only short-lived and vain hopes in themselves, but such, for the sake whereof we abridge ourselves of the pleasures and desires of the flesh, 1 John 3.3. and submit ourselves to the greatest sufferings in the world, Rom. 8.18. for the Hope of Israel am I bound with this chain &c. Acts 28.20. was this the Purchase of his blood? was this it, for which he sweat, and groaned, and bled, and died? was that precious blood no more worth than such a trifle as this?

(3) To what purpose did Christ rise again from the dead, was it not to be the first-fruits of them that sleep? did he not rise as the common Head of Believers? to give us assurance we shall not perish, and be utterly lost in the grave, Col. 1.18. But if our Souls perish at Death, there can be no Resurrection, and if none, then Christ died, and rose in vain, we are yet in our sins, and all those absurdities are unavoidable, with which the Apostle loads this supposition, 1 Cor. 15.13. &c.

(4) And to as little purpose was his Triumphant Ascen­sion into Heaven, if we can have no benefit by it. The pro­fessed end of his Ascension was to prepare a place for us, John 14.2. But to what purpose are those Mansions in the Heavens prepared, if the Inhabitants for whom they are prepared be utterly lost? And why is he called the fore­runner, if there be none to follow him, as surely there are not, if our Souls perish with our Bodies? Those Heavenly Mansions, that City prepared by God, must stand void for ever, if this be so.

(5) To conclude, in vain is the Intercession of Christ in Heaven for us, if this be so. They that shall never come thither, have no business there to be transacted by their advocate for them. So that the whole Doctrine of Redemp­tion by Christ is utterly subverted by this one supposition.

4. The work of the Spirit.

4. As it subverts the Doctrine of Redemption by Christ, and all the hopes and comforts we build thereon, so it ut­terly destroys all the works of the Spirit upon the hearts of Believers, and makes them vanish into nothing.

There are divers Acts and Offices of the Spirit of God a­bout and upon our Souls: I will only single out three, viz. his sanctifying, sealing, and comforting work; all, things of great weight with believers.

(1.) His sanctifying work, whereby he alters the frames and tempers of our Souls, 2 Cor. 5.17. old things are past a­way, behold, all things are become new.

The declared, and direct end of this work of the Spirit upon our Souls, is to attemper and dispose them for Hea­ven, Col. 1.12. For seeing nothing that is unclean can enter into the holy place, Rev. 21.27. And without holiness no man shall see the Lord, Heb. 12.14. It is necessary that all those that have this hope in them, should expect to be par­takers of their hopes in the way of purification, 1 John 3.3. And this is the ground upon which the people of God do mortify their lusts, and take so much pain with their own hearts, Matt. 18.8. counting it better (as their Lord tells them) to enter into life halt, or maimed, than having two eyes or hands to be cast into Hell. But to what purpose is all this self-denial, all these heart-searchings, heart-humblings, cries and tears upon the account of Sin, and for an heart suited to the will of God, if there be no such life to be en­joyed with God, after this animal life is finished?


If you say there is a present advantage resulting to us in this world, from our abstinence and self-denial, we have the truer, and longer enjoyment of our comforts on earth by it. Debauchery and licentiousness do not only flat the appetite, and debase and alloy the comforts of this World, but cut short our lives, by the exorbitances and abuses of them.


Though there be a truth in this, worth our noting, yet (1) Morality could have done all this without sanctifica­tion, there was no need for the pouring out of the Spirit, for so low a use and purpose as this. (2) And therefore as the wisdom of God would be censured and impeached, in sen­ding his spirit for an end, which could as well be attained without it, so the Veracity of God must needs be affronted by it, who, as you heard before, hath declared, our Salva­tion to be the end of our sanctification.

(2.) His Sealing, Witnessing and Assuring work: we have a full account in the Scriptures, of these Offices and works of the Spirit, and some spiritual sense and feeling of them up­on our own hearts, which are two good assurances, that there are such things as his bearing witness with our Spirits, Rom. 8.16. his Sealing us to the day of Redemption, Eph. 4.30. his earnests given into our hearts, 2 Cor. 1.22. All which acts and works of the Spirit, have a direct and clear aspect upon the life to come, and the happiness of our Souls in the full enjoyment of God to eternity. For it is to that life we are now sealed. And of the full sum of that glory, that these are the pledges and earnests. But if our Souls pe­rish by death, these witnesses of the spirit are Delusions, and his earnests are given us but in jest.

(3.) His Comforting work is a sweet fruit and effect sensibly felt and tasted by believers in this World. He is from this Office stiled the Comforter, John 16.7. signanter, & eminen­ter. He so comforts, as no other doth, or can. And what is the matter of his comforts, but the Blessedness to come, the joys of the coming World? John 16.13. Eye hath not seen, &c.

Upon the account of these unseen things, he enableth be­lievers to glory in tribulations, Rom. 5.4. to despise present things, whether the smiles or the frowns of the World, Heb. 11.24 & 26. But if the being of our Souls fail at death, these are but the Phantastick joys of men in a dream, and the experiences of all God’s people are found but so ma­ny fond conceits, and gross mistakes.

5. The Resurrection.

5. This supposition overthrows the Doctrine of the Resurrection, which is the consolation of Christians. We ac­cording to the Scripture believe, that after death hath di­vorced our Souls and Bodies for a time, they shall meet a­gain, and be reunited, and that the joy at their reunion will be to all that are in Christ, greater than the sorrows they felt at parting. This seems not incredible to us, what ever natural improbabilities and carnal reasons may be against it, Acts 26.8. And that because the Almighty power, which is able to subdue all things to himself, undertakes this task, Philip. 3.21.

We believe this very same numerical Body shall rise again, Job 21.27. by the return of the same Soul into it which now dwelleth in it, and that we shall be the same persons that now we are. The remunerative justice of God requiring it to be so.

We believe the Souls of the righteous shall be much bet­ter accommodated, and have a more comfortable habitation in their Bodies than now they have, 1 Cor. 15.42-43. see­ing they shall be made like unto Christ’s glorious Body, Phil. 3.21. And that then we shall live after the manner of An­gels, Luke 20.16. without the necessities of this animal life. These are the things we look for according to promise; and this expectation is our great relief against (1) the fears of death, 1 Cor. 15.55. (2) against the death of our Friends and Relations, 1. Thes. 4.14. (3) against all the pressures and afflictions of this life, Job 19.25-27.

But if the being of our Souls fail at death, all hopes and comforts from the Resurrection fail with it; for it is not I­maginable, that the body should rise, till it be revived, nor how it should be revived, but by the reunion of the Soul with it: and if it be not the same Soul that now inhabits it, we cannot be the same persons in the Resurrection we are now, and consequently, this supposition subverts not only the Doctrine of the Resurrection, but:

6. The future Judgment.

6. It overthrows also the faith of the Judgment to come. For if the Soul perish, the Body cannot rise, or if it rise by a new created Soul, the person raised is another, and not the same that lived and died in this World, and consequently, the re­wards and punishments to be bestowed and awarded to all men in that day, cannot be just and equal: for we believe, ac­cording to the Scriptures, that:

(1) The actions which men perform in this life, are not transient, but are filed to their account in the world to come, Gal. 6.7. “here we sow, and there we reap.” Actions done in this World are two ways consi­derable, viz. Physically, or Morally; in the first consideration they are transient, in the last, permanent and everlasting. A word is spoken, or an Act done, in a moment, but though it be past and gone, and perhaps by us quite forgot­ten, God registers it in his Book, in order to the day of ac­count.

(2) We believe that God hath appointed a day in which all men shall appear before his judgment seat, to give an ac­count of all they have done in the Body, whether it be good or evil. 2 Cor. 5.10.

(3) And that in order hereunto, the very same persons shall be restored by the Resurrection, and appear before God, the very same Bodies and Souls, which did good or evil in this World: shall not the Judge of all the earth do right? Justice requires that the rewards and punishments be then distributed to the same persons that did good or evil in this World: which strongly infers the immortality of the Soul, and that it certainly overlives the Body, and must come back from the respective places of their abode, to be again united to them, in order to their great account.

By all which you see the clearest proof of the Souls Im­mortality, and how the contrary supposition overthrows our Faith, Duties, and Comforts. Yet all this notwithstanding, how apt are we to suspect this Doctrine, and re­main still dissatisfied and doubting about it, when all is said? Which comes to pass partly from:

(1) The subtlety of Satan, who knows he can never persuade men to live the life of Beasts, till he first persuade them to think they shall die as the Beasts do, (and partly from the influence of Sense and Reason upon us, whereby we do too much suffer ourselves to be swayed, and imposed upon in matters of greatest mo­ment in Religion. For these being proper Arbiters and Judges in other matters within their Sphere, they are arro­gant, and we easy enough to admit them, to be Arbiters al­so in things that are quite above them; hence come such plausible objections as these:

Objection. 1.

The Soul seems to vanish and die, when it leaves the Body, for when it hath struggled as long as it can, to keep its possession in the Body, and at last is forced to depart; we can perceive nothing but a puff of breath, which immediate­ly vanishes into air, and is lost.


We cannot perceive, therefore it is nothing but what we do, and can perceive, viz. a puff of vanishing breath! By this argument the being of the Soul in the Body is as que­stionable, as after its departure out of the Body: for we cannot discern it by sight in the Body, yea, by this Argument, we may as well deny the existence of God and Angels, as of Souls, for it is a spiritual and invisible being, as they are, our gross senses are incapable of discerning Spirits, which are immaterial and invisible substances.

Objection. 2.

But you allow the Soul to have a rise and beginning, it is not eternal à parte anté, and it is certain, what ever had a beginning must have an end.


Every thing which had a beginning may have an end, and what once was nothing, may by the power that created it, be reduced to nothing again. But though we allow it may be so, by the absolute power of God, we deny the conse­quence, that therefore it shall and must be so. Angels had a beginning, but shall never have an end. And indeed their Immortality, as well as ours, flows not so much from the nature of either, as from the will and pleasure of God, who hath appointed them to be so. He can, but never will annihilate them.

Objection. 3.

But the Soul depends upon matter in all its operations, nothing is in the Understanding which was not first in the Senses; it useth the natural Spirits as its Servants and Tools in all its Operations, and therefore how can it either subsist or act in a State of Separation?


1. The Hypothesis is not only uncertain, but certainly false. There are acts performed by the Soul, even whilst it is in the Body, wherein it makes no use at all of the Bo­dy. Such are the acts of Self-intuition, and Self-reflection: and what will you say of its Acts in Raptures and Ecstasies, such as that of Paul, 2 Cor. 12.2. and John, Rev. 21.10. what use did their Souls make of the bodily senses or natu­ral Spirits then?

2. And though in its ordinary actions in this life, it doth use the Body, as its Tool or Instrument in working, doth it thence follow, that it can neither subsist or act separate from them in the other World? Whilst a man is on Horse­back in his Journey, he useth the help and service of his Horse, and is moved according to the motion of his Horse, but doth it thence follow, he cannot stand or walk alone, when dismounted at his Journeys end? We know Angels both live, and act, without the ministry of Bodies, and our Souls are Spiritual Substances as well as they.

Objection. 4.

But many Scriptures seem to favour the total cessation of the Souls actions, if not of its being also after Separation, as that in 2 Sam. 14.14. We must needs die, and are as wa­ter spilt upon the ground which cannot be gathered up, and Psal. 88.10-12. with Isaiah 38.18-19. The dead cannot praise thee.


Those words of the Woman of Tekoa, are not to be un­derstood absolutely, but respectively: and the meaning is, that the Soul is in the Body as some precious liquor in a brit­tle glass, which being broken by death, the Soul is irrecove­rably gone, as the Water Spilt on the ground, which by no humane power or art of man can be recovered again. All the means in the World cannot fetch it back into the Body again. She speaks not of the Resurrection, or what shall be done in the World to come, by the Almighty power of God, but of what is impossible to be done in this World by all the skill and power of Man.

And for the expression of Heman, and Hezekiah, they on­ly respect and relate to those services their Souls were now employed about for the praise of God, with respect to the conversion or edification of others, as Psal. 30.8-9. or at most, to that mediate service and worship, which they give God, in and by their attendance upon his ordinances in this World, and not of that immediate Service and praise, that is performed and given him in Heaven, by the Spirits of just men made perfect, such was the sweetness they had found in these Ordinances and Duties, that they express themselves as loth to leave them.

The same answer solves also the Objections grounded upon other mistaken Scriptures, as that Psal. 78.39. where man is called a wind that passeth away, and cometh not again. It is only expressive of the frailty and vanity of the present ani­mal life we live in this World, to which we shall return no more after death; it denies not life to departed Souls, but the end of this animal life at death, the life we live in the o­ther World, is of a different nature.

Inference I.

Is the Soul Immortal? Then, ’tis impossible for Souls to find full rest and contentment in any enjoyments on this side Hea­ven. All temporary things are inadequate; and therefore unsatisfying to our Souls What gives the Soul rest and satisfaction, must be as durable as the Soul is; for if we could possibly find in this World a condition and state of things most agreeable in all other respects to our desires and wishes, yet if the Soul be conscious to itself, That it shall and must over-live, and leave them all behind it, it can never reach true contentment in the greatest affluence and confluence of them. Man being an immortal, is there­fore a prospecting Creature, and can never be satisfied with this, That it’s well with him at present, except he can be satisfied that it shall be so for ever. The thoughts of leaving our delightful and pleasant enjoyments, imbitters them all to us whilst we have them. All outward things are in fluxu continuo, passing away as the Waters, 1 Cor. 7.31. Riches are uncertain, 1 Tim. 6.17. “They fly away as an Eagle towards Heaven, and with Wings of their own making, Prov. 23.5. (i.e.) as the Feathers that enable a Bird to fly from us, grow out of his own substance, so doth that vanity that carries away all earthly enjoyments. This alone would spoil all contentment.

Inference II.

Then see the ground and reason of Satan’s envy and enmity a­gainst the Soul, and his restless designs and endeavours to destroy it. It grates that Spirit of envy, to find himself, who is by nature Immortal, sunk everlastingly and irreco­verably into misery, and the Souls of Men appointed to fill up those vacant places in Heaven, from which the An­gels fell. No Creature but Man is envied by Satan, and the Soul of Man much more than his Body: ‘Tis true, he afflicts the Bodies of Men, when God permits him, but he ever aims at the Soul when he wounds the Body, Heb. 10.37. This roaring Lion is continually going about, seeking whom he may devour, 1 Pet. 5.8. ‘Tis the precious Soul he hunts after; that’s the Morsus Diaboli, the Bit he gapes for, as the Woolf tears the Fleece to come at the Flesh. All the pleasure those miserable Creatures find, is the suc­cess of their temptations upon the Souls of Men. ‘Tis a kind of delight to them to plunge. Souls into the same condemna­tion and misery with themselves. This is the trade they have been driving ever since their Fall. By destroying Souls, he at once exercises his revenge against God, and his envy a­gainst man, which is all the relief his miserable condition allows him.

Inference III.

Do the Souls of Men overlive their Bodies? Then ’tis the height of madness and spiritual Infatuation, to destroy the Soul for the Body’s sake. To cast away an Immortal Soul for the gratification of perishing flesh: to ruin the precious Soul for ever, for the pleasures of sin, which are but for a moment, yet this is the madness of millions of Men. They will drown their own Souls, in everlasting perdition, to procure unnecessary things for the Body, 1 Tim. 6.9. “They that will be rich,&c. Every cheat and circumvention in dealing, every lie, every act of oppression, is a wound gi­ven the Immortal Soul for the procuring some accommoda­tions to the Body.

O what Soul-undoing bargains do some make with the Devil! Some sell their Souls outright for the gratifica­tion of their lusts, 1 King. 21.20. Many pawn their Souls to Satan in a conditional bargain, so do all that venture up­on sin, upon a presumption of pardon and repentance. The Devil is a great trader for Souls: he hath all sorts of commodities to suit all mens humours that will deal with him. He hath profits for the Covetous, Honours for the Ambitious, pleasures for the Voluptuous, but a Soul is the price at which he sells them, only he will be con­tent to sell at a day, and not require present pay: so that it be paid on a death-bed, in a dying hour, he is satisfied. But oh, What an undoing bargain do sinners make! To part with a treasure for a trifle, Mat. 16.26. the precious Soul for ever, “for the pleasures of sin which are but for a season! Heb. 11.25. We are charmed with the present pleasure and sweetness there is in sin, but how bitter will the after fruits thereof be! See the Texts in the Margin (Prov. 20.17; 23.31-32; Job 20.12-13; James 1.15), you will say hereafter as Jonathan did, 1 Sam. 14.43. “I tasted but a little honey, and I must die.

Inference IV.

Then the exposing of the Body to danger, yea, to certain de­struction, for the preservation of the Soul, is the dictate of spiritual wisdom, and that which every Christian is bound to choose and practise, when both Interests come in full opposition (Heb. 11.35; Dan. 3.28; Rev. 12.11). No promises of pre­ferment, no threats of Torments, have been able to pre­vail with the people of God to give the least wound, or do the least wrong to their own Souls. When Secundus was commanded to deliver his Bible, he answered, Christianus sum, non Traditor—I am a Christian, I will not deliver it. Then they desired him but to deliver aliquam ecvolam, a Chip, a Straw, anything that came to his hand in lieu of it, he re­fused to redeem his life by delivering the least trifle on that account to save it.

That is a great word of our Lords, Luke 9.24. He that will save his life, shall lose it, and he that loseth it for my sake, shall find it. Christians, this is your duty and wisdom, and must be your resolution and practice in the day of Tempta­tion, to yield your Bodies to preserve your Souls, as we offer our arm to defend the head. O better thy Body had never been given thee, than that it should be a snare to thy Soul, and the instrument of casting it away for ever. O how dear are some persons like to pay for their tenderness and indulgence to the flesh, when the hour of Temptation shall come! Mortify your irregular affections to the Body, and never hazard your precious Immortal Souls for their sakes. ‘Tis the character of an Hypocrite to chuse sin rather than affliction. Job 36.21. But if ever thou hast been in the deeps of spiritual troubles for sin, if God have opened thine eyes to see the evil of sin, the immense weight and value of thy Soul, and of Eternity, “Thou wilt not count thy life dear to thee to finish thy course with joy, Act. 20.24.

Inference V.

If the Soul be an Immortal being, that shall have no end, Then ’tis the great concern of all men to strive to the utmost for the Salvation of their Souls, what ever become of all lesser tempora­ry interests in this world, Luke 13.24. There is a gate (i.e.) an introductive means of life and Salvation: this gate is strait, (i.e.) there are a world of difficulties to be encountered in the way of Salvation: but he that values and loves his never-dying Soul, must and will be diligent and constant in the use of all those means that have a tendency to Salvation, be they never so difficult or unpleasant to flesh and blood. There be difficulties from within ourselves, such as mortification, self-denial, contempt of the World, parting with all at the Call of Christ: and difficulties from without, the reproaches, persecutions and sufferings for Christ, which would not be so great as they are, were it not for our unmortified lusts within; but be they what they will, we are bound to strive through them all, for the Sal­vation of our precious and Immortal Souls.

(1) For ’tis the greatest concernment of the Soul, yea, of our own Souls; we are bound to do much for the saving of another’s Soul, 2 Tim. 2.10. much more for our own, this is our darling, Psal. 22. our only one.

(2) Others have done and suffered much for the saving of their Souls, and are not ours, or ought they not to be as dear to us, as the Souls of any others have been to them? Matt. 21.32.

(3) The utmost diligence is little enough to save them. Do all that you can do, and suffer all that you can suffer, and deny yourselves as deeply as ever any did, yet you shall find all this little enough to secure them, 1. Pet. 4.18. The righteous themselves are scarcely saved, 1 Cor. 9.24.

(4) The time to strive for Salvation is very short and un­certain, Luke 13.25; John 12.35. ‘Twill be to no purpose, when the seasons and opportunities of Salvation are once over. There is no striving in Hell, a death-pang of despair hath seized them, hope is extinguished, and endeavours fail.

(5) Doth not Reason dictate and direct you, to do now, whilst you are in the way, as you will wish you had done, and repent with rage, and self-indignation, because you did it not, when you come to the end and behold the final issues of things? Suppose but thyself now either (1) upon a death-bed lanching into Eternity; (2) or at the bar of Christ; (3) or in view of Heaven; (4) or in the sight and hearing of the damned: what think you, will you not then with, Oh that I had spent every moment in the World, that could possibly be redeemed from the pure necessities of life, in Prayer, in hearing, in striving for Salvation! From a prospect of this it was, that one spent many hours daily on his knees to the macerating of his Body; and being admonished of the danger of health, and advised to relax, he answered, I must die, I must die.

Objection. 1.

Do not say, you have many incumbrances, and other imployments in the Word; for (1) one thing is necessary, Luke 10.42. Those are conveniences, but this is of absolute necessity. (2) They will thrive the better for this, Mat. 6.33. seek this, and they shall be added. (3) Do but re­deem the time that can be redeemed to this purpose, let not so much precious time run waste as daily doth.

Objection 2.

Say not, no man can save his Soul by his own striving, and therefore ’tis to little purpose, for it is not of him that willeth, or of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth mercy, Rom. 9.16.

True, this in itself cannot save you, but what then? must we oppose those things which God hath subordinated? bring this home to your natural or civil actions, eating, drinking, Plowing or Sowing, and see how the consequence will look.

Objection. 3.

Say not ’tis a mercenary Doctrine, and disparages free Grace. For are not all the enjoyments and comforts of this life confessedly from free Grace, though God hath dispensed them to you in the way of your diligence and industry?

Objection. 4.

To conclude, say not the difficulties of Salvation are in­superable; ’tis so hard to watch every motion of the heart, to deny every lust, to resist a suitable temptation, to suffer the loss of all for Christ, that there is no hope for overco­ming them.

For (1) God can and doth make difficult things easy to his people, who work in the strength of Christ, Philip. 4.13 (2) These same difficulties are before all others that are before you, yet it discourageth not them, Philip. 3.11. Others strive to the uttermost. There are extreams found in this matter: some work for Salvation, as an hireling for his wages, so the Papists; these disparage Grace, and cry up works. Others cry down obedience as legal, as the Antino­mians, and cry up grace to the disparagement of duties: avoid both these, and see that you strive, but (1) think not Heaven to be the price of your striving, Rom. 4.3. (2) strive, but not for a spurt; let this care and diligence run throughout your lives, whilst you are living, be you still striving: your Souls are worth it, and infinitely more than all this amounts to.

Inference VI.

Doth the Soul overlive the Body, and abide for ever? Then ’tis a great evil and folly to be excessively careful for the mortal Body, and neglective of the immortal Inhabitant. In a too much indulged Body, there ever dwells a too much neglected Soul.

The Body is but a vile thing, Philip. 3.21. the Soul more valuable than the whole World, Matt. 16.26. to spend time, care, and pains for a vile Body, whilst little or no regard is had to the precious Immortal Soul, is an unwarranta­ble folly and madness. To have a clean, and washed Body, and a Soul all filth (as one speaks) a Body neatly clothed and dressed, with a Soul all naked and unready: a Body fed, and a Soul starved; a Body full of the Creature, and a Soul empty of Christ: these are poor Souls indeed. We smile at little children, who in a kind of laborious idleness, take a great deal of pains to make and trim their ba­bies, or build their little houses of Sticks and straws. And what are they but children of a bigger size, that keep such ado about the Body, a house of Clay? a weak pile, that must perish in a few days! ‘Tis admirable, and very convictive of most Christians what we read in an Heathen. I confess (saith Seneca) there is a love to the Body im­planted in us all, we have the Tutelage and charge of it, we may be kind and indulgent to it, but must not serve it, but he that serves it, is a servant to many cares, fears and passi­ons. Let us have a diligent care of it, yet so as when Rea­son requires, when our Dignity or faith requires it, we com­mit it to the fire.

‘Tis true, the Body is beloved of the Soul, and God re­quires that it moderately care for the necessities and con­veniences of it, but to be fond, indulgent, and constantly solicitous about it, is both the sin, and snare of the Soul. One of the Fathers being invited to dine with a Lady, and waiting some hours till she was drest, and fit to come down, when he saw her, he fell a weeping, and being demanded why he wept, O saith he, I am troubled that you should spend so many hours this morning in pinning and trimming your Body, when I have not spent half the time in Praying, Repenting, and caring for my own Soul. Two things a Master commits to his Servants care, (saith one) the Child, and the Child’s clothes: it will be but a poor excuse for the Servant to say, at his Masters return, Sir, here are all the Child’s clothes neat and clean, but the child is lost. Much so will be the account that many will give to God of their Souls and Bodies at the great day. Lord, here is my Body, I was very careful for it, I neglected nothing that belonged to its content and welfare; but for my Soul, that is lost, and cast away for ever, I took little care or thought about it. ‘Tis remarkable what the Apostle saith, Rom. 8.12. We owe nothing to the flesh, we are not in its debt, we have given it all, more than all that belongs to it; but we owe many an hour, many a care, many a deep thought to our Souls, which we have defrauded it of, for the vile Bo­dies sake. You have robbed your Souls, to pay your flesh. This is madness.

Inference VII.

How great a blessing is the Gospel which brings life and im­mortality to light, the most desirable mercies to immortal Souls? This is the great benefit we receive by it, as the A­postle speaks, 2 Tim. 1.10. “Christ hath abolished death, and brought life and immortality to light by the Gospel.” Life and im­mortality by a ἓν διὰ δυοῖν [hendiadys], is put for immortal life, the thing which all immortal Souls desire and long for. These desires are found in Souls that enjoy not the Gospel-light; for as I said before, they naturally spring out of the very nature of all immortal Souls But how, and where it is to be obtained, that is a secret, for which we are entirely behold­ing to the Gospel-discovery. It lay hid in the Womb of God’s purpose, till by the light of Gospel Revelation it was made manifest. But now all men may see what are the gracious thoughts and purposes of God concerning men, and what that is he hath designed for their Immortal Souls even an Immortal life, and this life is to be obtained by Christ, than which, no tidings can be more welcome, sweet or ac­ceptable to us.

O therefore study the Gospel. “This is life eternal, to know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom thou hast sent,” John 17.3. And see that you prize the Gospel above all earthly Treasures: ‘Tis a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation: you have two inestimable benefits and blessings by it. (1) It manifests and reveals eternal life to you, which you could never have come to the knowledge of, any other way: those that are without it, are groping or feeling af­ter God in the dark, Acts 17.27. Poor Souls are consci­ous to themselves, that there is a just and terrible God, and that their sins offend and provoke him, but how to atone the offended Deity, they know not, Mica. 6.6-7. But the way of Reconciliation and life is clearly discovered to us by the Gospel. (2) As it manifests and reveals Eter­nal life to us, so it frames and moulds our hearts, as God’s sanctifying Instrument, for the enjoyment of it. ‘Tis not only the Instrument of Revelation, but of Salvation, the word of life, as well as the word of light, Philip. 2.16. It can open your hearts as well as your eyes: and is therefore to be entertained as that which is the first rank of Blessings, a peerless and inestimable Blessing.

Inference VIII.

If our Souls be immortal, certainly our enemies are not so formidable, as we are apt by our sinful fears to represent them. They may, when God permits them, destroy your Bodies, they cannot touch or destroy your Souls, Mat. 16.28. As to your Bodies, no enemy can touch them till there be leave and permission given them by God, Job 1.10. The Bo­dies of the Saints as well as their Souls are within the line or hedge of Divine Providence. They are securely fenced, sometimes mediately by the ministry of Angels, Psal. 34.7. And sometimes immediately, by his own hand and power, Zech. 2.5. As to their Souls, whatever power Enemies may have upon them, (when divine permission opens a gap in the hedge of Providence for them) yet they cannot reach their Souls to hurt them, or destroy them, but by their own consent. They can destroy our pe­rishing flesh, it is obnoxious to their malice and rage; they cannot reach home to the Soul: no Sword can cut asunder the band of Union betwixt them and Christ: they would be dreadful Enemies indeed if they could do so. Why then do we tremble and fear at this rate as if Soul and Body were at their mercy, and in their power and hand? The Souls of those Martyrs were in safety under the Al­tar in Heaven, they were clothed with white Robes, when their Bodies were given to be meat to the Fowls of Heaven, and Beasts of the Earth. The Devil drives but a poor trade by the persecution of the Saints; he tears the nest, but the bird escapes: he cracks the Shell, but loseth the Kernel. Two things make a powerful defensative against our fears, (1) That all our Enemies are in the hand of Providence. (2) That all providences are steered by that promise, Rom. 8.28.

Inference IX.

If Souls be Immortal, Then there must needs be a vast dif­ference betwixt the aspects and influences of death, upon the Godly and Ungodly.

O if Souls would but seriously consider what an alteration death will make upon their condition, for evil or for good: how useful would such meditations be to them. (1) They must be disseized, and turned out of these houses of Clay, and live in a state of separation from them: of this there is an inevitable necessity, Eccles. 8.8. ‘Tis in vain to say, I am not ready, ready or unready, they must depart when their lease is out. ‘Tis as vain to say, I am not willing, for willing or unwilling, they must be gone, there’s no hanging back and begging, Lord, let death take another at this time, and spare me; for no man dies by a Proxy. (2) The time of our Souls departure is at hand, 2 Pet. 1.13-14; Job 16.22. The most firm and well built body can stand but a few days, but our ruinous Tabernacles give our Souls warning, that the day of their departure is at hand. The lamp of life is almost burnt down, the glass of time almost run: yet a few, a very few days and nights more, and then time, nights and days shall be no more. (3) When that most certain, and near approaching time is come, wonderful alterations will be made on the state of all Souls, Godly and Ungodly.

(1) A marvellous alteration will then be made on the Souls of the Godly. For (1) no sooner is the dividing stroke given by death, and the parting pull over, but they shall find themselves in arms of Angels, mounting them through the upper Regions in a few moments, far above all the aspectable Heavens, Luke 16.22. The airy Region is indeed the place where Devils inhabit, and have their haunts and walks; but Angels are the Saints’ Convoy through Satan’s Territories from the arms of mourning Friends, into the welcome arms of officious and benevolent Angels. (2) from the sight and converses of men, to the sight of God, Christ, and the general assembly of blessed and sinless Spirits. The Soul takes its leave of all men at death, Isa. 38.11. Fare­well vain World, with all the mixed and imperfect com­forts of it, and welcome the more sweet, suitable and sa­tisfying company of Father, Son, and Spirit, holy Angels, and perfected Saints, Heb. 12.23. (3) From the bondage of corruption, to perfect liberty, and everlasting freedom, so much is implied, Heb. 12.23. The Spirits of just men made perfect. (4) From all fears, doubtings, and questionings of our conditions, and anxious debates of our title to Christ, to the clearest, fullest, and most satisfying assurance: for what a man sees, how can he doubt of it? (5) From all burdens of affliction, inward and outward, under which we have groaned all our days, to everlasting rest and ease, 2 Cor. 5.1-3. O what a blessed change to the righteous must this be?

(2) A marvellous change will also be then made upon the Souls of the ungodly, who shall then part from, (1) all their comforts and pleasant enjoyments in the World, for here they had their consolation, Luke 16.25 here was all their Portion, Psal. 17.14. And in a moment find themselves arrested and seized by Satan, as God’s jailer, hurrying them away to the prison of Hell, 1 Pet. 3.19. “There to be reserved to the judgment of the great day,” Jude 6. (2) From under the means of Grace, Life, and Salvation, to a state perfectly void of all means, instruments, and opportunities of Salvation (John 9.4; Eccles. 9.10), never to hear the joyful sound of preaching or praying any more, never to hear the wooing voice of the blessed Bridegroom, saying, Come unto me, come unto me, any more. (3) From all their vain, ungrounded presumptuous hopes of Heaven, into abso­lute and final desperation of mercy. The very sinews and nerves of hope are cut by death, Prov. 14.32. The wicked is dri­ven away in his wickedness, but the righteous hath hope in his death. These are the great and astonishing alterations that will be made upon our Souls, after they part with the Bodies which they now inhabit. O that we who cannot but be conscious to ourselves, that we must overlive our Bodies, were more thoughtful of the condition they must enter into, after that separation which is at hand.

Inference X.

If our Souls be Immortal, Then death is neither to be feared by them in Heaven, nor hoped for by them in Hell. The be­ing of Souls never fails, whether they be in a state of bles­sedness or of misery. “In glory they are ever with the Lord, 1 Thes. 4.17. There shall be no death there, Rev. 21.4. And in Hell, though they shall wish for death, yet death shall flee from them. Though there be no fears of annihilation in Heaven, yet there be many vain wishes for it in Hell: but to no purpose; there never will be an end put either to their being, or to their torments. In this respect no other Creature is capable of the misery that wicked men are capable of when they die, there is the end of all their misery; but it is not so with Men. Better therefore had it been for them, if God had created them in the basest and lowest order and rank of Creatures; a dog, a toad, a worm is better than a Man in endless misery, ever dying, and never dead.

And so much of the Soul’s Immortality.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s